Reader Request: Lululemon Toasty Tech Tights vs. Keep The Fleece Tights

November 21, 2018

Thanks to reader Ms. D for putting in this request! I appreciate being able to help! On Monday, Lululemon uploaded last years Toasty Tech Tight II‘s to the Canadian site, but with a big hefty price increase, and more importantly, a big price difference with the competing Keep The Fleece Tights. The Keep The Fleece Tights sit at $128, and the  Toasty Tech Tight II are $148. Both are tech fleece fabric and have subtle design differences, but overall they have the exact same function, same material and same construction quality. I like both a lot but not sure the difference in price is worth it unless you have a distinct style preference.

Toasty Tech Tight II

For the Toasty Tech Tight II’s, I really love the quilting pattern at the side, and I love the matte purple color I have which Is black grape. I don’t love the contrasting waistband though so I would probably gravitate more to the new Cyber color. Comparing the fit to the Keep The Fleece, these feel less compressive and higher in the waist. They may be less compressive because they’ve stretched out after some wear over the years but I think the ribbed bands and seam details on the Keep The Fleece help retain shape as well. These are the same length as the Keep The Fleece but because there isn’t the zipper detailing at the hem and it’s a narrower cut it looks less obviously too long. There is less pooling and bunching at the hem. 

Lululemon Toasty Tech Tight II
Lululemon Toasty Tech Tight II

Buy The Toasty Tech Tight II Here

Toasty Tech Tight II

Keep The Fleece Tight

I know a lot of people aren’t fans of the ribbed panels across the legs and they definitely can be visually less lengthening, but I love the edgy motto look to them. I really love the zipper at the ankle as well and generally gravitate to this pair over my other pair but that may be due to the color being more neutral. This just looks ‘outfit worthy’ for a big oversized slouchy sweater and scarf while the other pair looks like ‘I’m out for a pre dawn winter run before dropping the kids off at school’. After a day of wearing these you can definitely feel the seams across the thighs which is not an issue you would have with the Toasty Tech Tight. They aren’t tight or feel uncomfortable on me but I do notice the seams so it’s worth noting. 

Lululemon Keep The Fleece Tight
Keep The Fleece Tight

Buy The Keep The Fleece Tight Here

So there you have it! Both are equally suitable for winter running although neither are quite warm enough for sub -20* runs, but perfect for mild west coast winter runs. Both are cozy and cute, but you may have a style preference for one over the other or a pricing preference. I highly recommend both. Hope that helps! 

Wunder Under Crop Ribbed
Wunder Under Crop Ribbed
Scuba Crew
Scuba Pullover
Define Jacket Nulux
Swiftly Speed Polo
Extra Mile Jacket
Refresh maxi dress
Define Jacket Nulux
Define Jacket Nulux
Define Jacket Nulux
Iconic Sweat Bra
Iconic Sweat Tight
Align Pant
Fast & Free Tight
Swiftly Tech Breeze
Scuba Hoodie
Forget The Sweat Tight
Forget The Sweat Tight
Sooth Away Hoodie
Love Tee Fade
Love Crew Fade
Love Crew Fade
Unwind Your Mind Dress
The Rain Is Calling Jacket II
catch a moment zip up hoodie
always effortless jacket
City Stroll Jacket
Catch A Moment Hoodie
Catch A Moment Hoodie
Wunder Under Hi Rise Tight
Chill On Pullover
Love Crew International Women’s Day
Define Jacket
Define Jacket
Define Jacket
Noir Crop
Noir Crop
Speed Up Tight
Rest Less Pullover
Hello Sunday Crop
Scuba Hoodie
Scuba Hoodie
Chill On Pullover
On The Fly Pant Frontier
Fast & Free Tight Incognito Camo Gator Green
Define Jacket
In The Clear Jacket
So Sherpa Jacket
Swiftly Tech Racerback
Swiftly Tech LS Crew
To The Beat Duffel
To The Beat Tee
Ride & Reflect Jacket
Ride & Reflect Jacket
To The Beat Sweatshirt
To The Beat Sweatshirt
To The Beat Tight Reflective
To The Beat Tight Reflective
Ride & Reflect Tight
Ride & Reflect Tight
Time To Restore Sweater
Define Jacket
Push Your Pace Jacket
Fast & Free Tight
Starting Place Hoodie
Pleat Perfection Jacket
Pleat Perfection Jacket
So Sherpa Hooded Jacket
Painted Paisley
Wunder Under Crop Flocked
Scuba Hoodie Plush
Wunder under flocked
Coast Hoodie
Coast Easy Wrap
Define Jacket Flocked
Scuba Hoodie Frosted Rose
Fast & Free Crop II
So Sherpa Hooded Jacket
So Sherpa Hooded Jacket
Swiftly Tech LS Crew Sparkle
Forever Warm Pullover
So Sherpa Hooded Jacket
Sit In Lotus Sweater
Sit In Lotus Sweater
Sit In Lotus Sweater
Sit In Lotus Sweater
Define Jacket
On Repeat Jacket
Toasty Tech Tight
Down For It All Jacket
Calm & Cozy Jacket
Calm & Cozy Jacket
Wunder Under Floral
Wunder Under Super-Hi-Rise
Keep The Heat Thermal Tight, Lululemon Wool Blend Tights
Keep The Heat Thermal Hoodie
Down For It All Vest
Define Jacket Garment Dye
On Repeat Dress
Down For It All Pullover, Fools Gold
Fast & Free Full Length Tight
Dance Studio Jacket Ribbed
Wunder Under Super-Hi-Rise
Define Jacket Full On Luxtreme
Train Times 7/8 Tight
Swiftly Tech Long Sleeve
Bring The Cozy Turtleneck
Bring The Cozy Turtleneck
Bring The Cozy Turtleneck
Dance Studio Jogger
Movement To Movement Jacket
Brisk Running Hoodie
Align Crop Incognito Camo
Keep The Fleece Tights
Dance Studio Jacket Ribbed
Dance Studio Jacket Ribbed
Down For It All Jacket
Swiftly Wool Tight
Aurora Jacket
Aurora Jacket
Call It Cozy Wrap
Call It Cozy Wrap
Time To Thrive Jacket
Time To Thrive Jacket
Time To Thrive Jacket
Down For It All Jacket
Down For It All Jacket
Down For It All Jacket
City Trek Turtleneck
City Trek Turtleneck
Tracker Short V
Inked Wunder Under Ice Grey
Stride Jacket II
Find Focus 7/8 Tight
Patch Game Jacket
Patch Game Short
City Trek Turtleneck
Wunder Under Crop Hi Rise
Swiftly Wool Pullover
Find Focus Tight
Like Nothing Bra
Ready To Rulu Pant
Cloudscape Jacket
Never Still Crop
Melodic Movement
Masons Peak Flannel
High Lines Pullover
Sweat  Strength Crop
Cypress Kiss Long Sleeve
High Lines Pullover
Pick Your Path Jacket
Pack It Up Jacket Camo
Pack it Up Jacket
The Rain Is Calling Jacket II
Ventilate Jacket
Run The Course Crop
Set Free Run Tank
Enlite Bra
Get Going Train Tight
Hearts Compass Poncho
Rest Less 1/2 Zip
The Rain Is Calling III
Energy Bra 20Y
Scuba Hoodie 20Y
Sculpt Long Sleeve
Never Still Hoodie
Huddle & Hustle Hoodie
Fleece Of Mind Jacket
On The Fly Pant
20Y Collection
Scuba Hoodie
Start Anew Skirt
Pack It Up Jacket
Dance Studio Jacket III
Front Of The Pack 1/2 Zip
Melodic Movement Tight
Moment To Movement Tight
Define Jacket Nulux
Swiftly Tech Racerback
Through The Movement Tank
Swiftly Tech SS Crew
Swiftly Tech Breeze
Festival Bag II
Festival Bag II
Swiftly Tech SS Crew
Cool Racerback II Nulu
Run Times Short II
Align Crop Incognito Camo
On The Fly Pant Wide
Rain Rules Jacket
Find Your Focus Short Sleeve
Dance Studio Crop
Photo Finish Skirt
Photo Finish Skirt
Attack The Track Short
Attack The Track Short
Laser Speed Jacket
Laser Speed Jacket
City Street Cardigan
Hooded Define Jacket
Rally Your Heart Tank
Ebb To Street Tank II
Spectrum Wunder Under
Speed Up Crop
Speed Up Tight
Speed Up Shorts
Speed Up Crop
In Movement 7/8 Tight
Breeze By Jogger Squad
On The Fly Skirt
On The Fly Skirt
Swiftly Tech LS Crew
Pack It Down Jacket
Pack It Down Vest
Pack It Down Vest
Pack It Down Vest
Pack It Down Jacket
Sculpt Tank II
Tracker Short V
Speed Up Short
Play Off The Pleats Skirt
Essential Tank
Spring Breakaway Short
Cool Racerback Nulu
Love Knot Crop
Train Times 7/8 Tight
Hotty Hot Short II
Speed Up Short
Wunder Under Hi Rise Tight
Hotty Hot Short II
Here To  Move Jacket
Here To Move Jacket
Here To Move Jacket
Uncaged Bra
Scuba Hoodie Light
For The Run Short Sleeve
Gait Keeper Short
Sweat Reps 2 In 1 Tank
Train Times 7/8 Pant
Free To Be Tank *Nulu
Create Your Calm Tank
Reveal Crop Interconnect
Define Jacket
Ebb To Street Tank II
Train Times Crops
Roll Around Tee *Expression
Tighten Up Tank
Well Being Sweater
Stash N’ Run Tank
Fast & Free Crop II
Reveal Crop
Reveal 7/8 Tight
Pace Rival Skirt Tall
Run Times Short II
Scuba Hoodie IV Fleece
Scuba Hoodie IV
On Pace Short
Essential Tank
Wunder Under Hi-Rise Tight MESH
Uncaged Bra
Fast and Free 7/8 Pant II
On Pace Crop
Wunder Under Pant Hi-Rise 7/8 Tight
Share:
13 comments so far.

13 responses to “Reader Request: Lululemon Toasty Tech Tights vs. Keep The Fleece Tights”

  1. Danika says:

    Cristina, THANK YOU!!!!! Appreciate how fast you put up this review! 🙂
    I need to go to a store and try to decide between these two. I am here in Vancouver and was planning to use them for snowshoeing on the North Shore.
    Again, thank you!

  2. j ps says:

    Thank you for the review 🙂 Are the side pockets the same size? I can’t fit my iphone with its case on my keep the fleece tights.

  3. Anonymous says:

    Cristina, thanks so much for the comparison! I have the dark sport red “Keep the Fleece” tight and love all of the fun details and zippers. I was hoping for another color option in those. The “toasty tech fleece” looks nice and I am eyeing the purple color, but they haven’t made their way to the States. I’m not sure if I want to spend that much so I’ll have to think it over.
    For those who want a basic cozy tight at a better price ($98.00) Athleta has the “Ridge tight” which is a fleece lined high waisted tight with side zip pockets. They come in two colors, black and navy. I would have bought the navy but they were sold out in the tall size I needed.
    To my Canadian friends, I’m hoping that Athleta will expand to Canada. I generally prefer Lululemon, but I do find some nice items at Athleta and they have some really good sales.

  4. Joanna says:

    Thank you for the comparison. I am one of those people how do not love the ribbed banding and feels like it cuts off the leg so to speak, making it look less flattering than the Toasty. I love the Toasty. I like the detailing a lot better (that quilted panel!), plus the rise on the Toasty is great for me (I’m 5’10). Admittedly, I have not tried the newest one that has come out; I am just going on photos and reviews. Yes, the fabric on the one I have is a tad shiny when stretched out, but I’m okay with it. The one I just got off the sale board, an all black pair, seem to have less shine than the pixie/blk combo and bordeaux that I used to own. I had the purple too and it was quite matte. I wonder if the new ones have the shiny look? Anyone else know what I am talking about?

  5. shadowy_lady says:

    You are the best Cristina. I missed out on Toasty Techs but I do run in the winter so this was great and helpful.
    I bought the Keep the Fleece tights earlier and have already ran in them a few times. This morning when I went for my run here in Ottawa it was -12C and also windy and I felt comfortable in them. I do not know how they will do in -20C but at that temperature I always layer my tights anyways (I like Icebreaker tights layered with sweat pants).

    I think I will jut buy another Keep the Fleece then. I wish we would get more colours in Canada. I am not too picky in terms of design difference between the two so I will go with the cheaper one.

  6. Anonymous says:

    I noticed a price increase in Calm and cozy Jacket 🙁 it was uploaded on Monday at $108 usd and now is $118! Am I crazy?! I was waiting to order it with some of the Black Friday stuff and now it’s more expensive

  7. NB says:

    LLL black Friday (WMTM) uploaded at 12am ET. Some decent discounts!! Got a backup principal dancer funnel neck and ready to rulu pants (knew those would go on sale based on the poor reviews this year). Happy Thanksgiving to the US, and happy shopping to all!

  8. Anonymous says:

    Women have to remember that the tights all look good on the models whom are advertising them. And most women just wear them because they are too lazy to dress in normal attire and want to look athletic when they are not. The products are all good quality and you get what you pay for. If you are hitting the gym or the trails you want quality products an

  9. Steve says:

    Women have to remember that the tights all look good on the models whom are advertising them. And most women just wear them because they are too lazy to dress in normal attire and want to look athletic when they are not. The products are all good quality and you get what you pay for. Work hard, play hard and wear quality, not does this make my butt look like I work out. Sad

    • Cristina says:

      The real test for these tights is whether or not I can clean and jerk you up over my head (I can) and then toss you back onto your mommy’s lap so that she can help YOU remember that nobody asked you, STEVEN!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.